
This past week I decided to join great bloggers like Paul Stamatiou, Derek Punsalan, Alex King, Glenn Wosley, Matt Brett, and James Mathias and purchased myself Logitech’s MX Revolution. I was planning on giving this mouse a thorough review, but judging from the number of bloggers who own this device, I think that’s been covered. Instead, I’m just going to go over my basic impressions of the mouse.
The Difficult Packaging
First off, no one seems to mention this; Logitech packaged the MX Revolution in the worst packaging they could find. Opening up my MX Revolution took nearly fifteen minutes due to the layers of cardboard and tape inside the box. The worst part of the whole ordeal was getting the mouse out of the airtight layer of plastic. Logitech gives instructions, but the instructions were not much help. I had to use excessive force on the plastic, praying that my new $100 toy would not go flying across the room.
The Horrible Mac Driver
After fighting my way through the packaging, setup was simple – until I had to install Logitech’s driver. While OS X recognizes the basic mouse functionality out of the box, all the extra buttons do not function without a driver. Logitech provides a Mac driver, but it’s the most horrible driver I’ve ever used. I found the Logitech driver does not recognize the receiver if it’s plugged into a USB hub, forcing me to plug the receiver directly into my MacBook. After recognizing the receiver, I had to configure the mouse quickly since the Logitech Control Center crashed often. Configuring it quickly was out of the question as any new application profiles had to be configured completely from scratch. Yeah, no default configuration here. Oh, I didn’t even mention LCC installs Unsanity’s Application Enhancer but hides the program from use. That would not be a problem if APE stopped recaching drivers on every reboot, and Logitech uninstalls APE with the driver.

As you can probably guess, I hate Logitech’s driver. After realizing my mistake, I saved myself the trouble and purchased SteerMouse. SteerMouse recognizes the receiver no matter what USB port I plug it into and does not crash or install extra bloat like Logitech’s driver. SteerMouse also offers greater flexibility in configuration, allowing me to assign any button to anything. Not to mention it natively supports the MX Revolution, giving me full control over the MX Revolution’s scroll wheel. Yes, I know the software costs extra and Logitech should provide a working driver, but I paid $100 for this mouse. I might as well spend a little extra to get the mouse to function correctly.
Conclusions
Barring setup, this mouse truly is wonderful. I know that’s hard to believe after my long rant, but I only need to setup the mouse once. The MX Revolution feels comfortable in my hand, the redesigned scroll wheel is natural, and the wireless functionality offers no noticeable lag. As far as battery life, I seem to get 4-7 days of battery life. The included docking charger is simple to use, making recharging the mouse not an issue. As far as productively, I setup my mouse identical to Matt Brett, which offers me lighting fast application switching.
Sure, the MX Revolution is expensive, but if you spend as much time on a computer as I do, investing in your number one input device is worthwhile. Just don’t make the same mistake I did; ditch the Logitech Control Center drivers before they cause you pain.
12 Comments
Good point on the fact that no one mentioned how horrible the packaging on these devices is. I actually managed to send mine through the air denting the right edge [after it hit my desk]. Aside from the initial setup woes that OS X users must endure, the mouse is an incredible piece of hardware.
Didn’t you mention on Twitter a week or so ago that your scroll wheel stopped functioning correctly? I wonder if the impact had anything to do with it.
Any scrolling malfunctioning that I experienced had something to do with the customization utility tool that I was using. I’ve been moving between SteerMouse, LCC, and ControllerMate.
It’s weird that you couldn’t plug your receiver into a USB hub. I’ve got mine plugged into my Apple keyboard, which is plugged into a USB hub, which is then plugged into my Powerbook, and it works fine. My USB hub is externally powered though, if you’re isn’t that might make a difference? I’ve only tried the Logitech software so far, but I might give SteerMouse a try now.
Agreed. I have mine plugged in through a USB hub which in turn is plugged into a second hub which goes to the computer.
That’s my exact setup. Receiver > Apple Keyboard > Powered Hub > MacBook. I thought at first the issue might have been that my Apple Keyboard is only USB1, but plugging the receiver directly into my MacBook showed me that receiver in fact only operated at USB1 speeds. I can’t explain it other than LCC is retarded.
Hi,
I just bought this mouse to replace my Microsoft wired mouse.
I love almost everything about it. Only 2 gripes:
1. I use FireFox and LOVE using the middle button (pressing the scroll wheel in) to open links in new tab. The big, heavy scroll wheel is VERY hard to press in without scrolling… which moves the link you were trying to open.
2. To get around this I wanted to make the “forward” button on the side of the mouse act like that middle button, but alas as Ronald says, the driver that comes with it does not allow for this particular customization. IDIOTS!!
I ended up changing the “search” button on the top of the mouse in a “middle button”, but it’s hard to reach without taking my fingers off the butons/scroll wheel.
Maybe I’ll invest in that other driver utility Ronald mentioned.
Thanks,
Dan
I guess I can’t brag about the drivers from Logitech, they have worked just fine for me. I currently have the white wireless keyboard/mouse combo, and LCC v2.1. I won’t dare to upgrade, as people report all these problems. 2.1 has been solid for me though. Always recognizes the devices, and no crashing.
Thank you for the link (to SteerMouse). I just grabbed the Revolution and quickly became addicted to the scroll wheel.. yet frustated with the v2.1.4 Control Center inablility to properly manage the device. Amazing that Logitech can make such amazing hardware but fail to deliver the software to support it.
For windows xp/vista users wanting more from logitech devices, check out the SetPoint replacement:
uberOptions
http://www.mstarmetro.net/~rlowens/
@ Matt
Thank you Matt for pointing me towards uberOptions! I really love this mouse but the supplied programs are terribly nerfed.
Really appreciate the link!
-A-
solution to open in new tab firefox/ie.
http://tinyurl.com/32ewt3
you can relly program and on the buttons to do this. I have one of my side buttons doing this.
hope this helps
-P
agreed to the packaging issues.. though it went out perfectly but took me a wile to guess how to take it out.. the drivers are as crappy on mac as on windows, beleive me.. especailly the new ones.. after u play some opengl or DX game, youll have to restart the application because it simply forgets what is bound to extra buttons. i tried it on both, xp and vista, and i kept getting same problem. i wish there were some alternative drivers for PC…